Joseph Kim
English 10
Compare and Contrast Essay
May 10, 2010
Reading book vs. Watching the movie
“Harry Potter book is out! Let’s go buy the book!” We don’t really hear that statement as much as we heed the statement, “Harry Potter is out on the theater! Let’s go watch it this weekend!” Books inspire people to make movie, which in-turns inspires those who didn’t read the book. While there are many and similarities between reading the book and watching the movie, there are differences that let each stand out on itself.
Some of the similarities between film and books include helping us relax, and for most people, it is an entertainment that people do most of the time. Both books and movies are highly recognized as things we do when we are bored. It is possible to think that books and movies are the same because they both give the same general idea behind the story. Not like video games, such as PS3, or X-box, books and movies are easy to carry and can entertain more than four people at the same time. Books and movies are good for all ages.
Positive things about movies vary, but the major one would be that they are so simple and relaxing thing to do especially when you are traveling and have nothing to do. Now days, movies can be in computer, mp3, and even cell-phones, which provides simpler ways for any people to watch movie at any place, and at any time. When you are in an airplane, sharing seat with a stranger, you can’t just turn on the light at night, just so you can read a book. But a movie in a mp3 player or a computer wouldn’t disturb the person and you can watch the movie and still get the same story as reading the book. Not only that, if you watch the movie instead of reading the book, you will be able to save time because most of you are not a fast readers, and if you try to read fast, you might miss out on an important information. For an example, if your English class teacher asked you to read Harry Potter in one day and write an essay about it, how would you be able to finish your task with confidence? As you know, if you had to read it, it would take more than two hours to finish the thick and long book. Where if you were watching the movie, it would take maximum two hours to finish and get the same idea as the book. Then, you will have more time to write on your essay and have confidence with the work.
Positive things about the books may vary from person to person, but the major one would be that books contain small details. Although books take little more time to finish, compared to movies, books gives more entertainment in a way, than films because they are so flexible with different points of view of the idea of the story. Movies lack incredibly with small details mainly because it simply cannot be seen with our eyes. For an example, in Harry Potter, the book says, “Harry thought to himself, that Ron is actually handsome,” how would the movie show that? Books give generally more details so that we can “watch” the story behind our eyelids. Our imaginations are amazingly good at showing the story behind the book with our point of view, whereas, movies are shown in the director’s point of view, about the story; which explains why a lot of people say, “I thought the movie was quite lame” or “I think the movie could have been better.” Only few people are satisfied with how the movie was showing the idea of the story. Most of the people expected more or less with the movie because they had another perspective to the story. A good example would be the movie Star Wars. What if you are a fan of Dark Vader? Since Dark Vader and Skywalker is the same person, shouldn’t the movie show Dark Vader as unfortunate villain character? But instead, the movie shows Dark Vader as the dreadful villain. Films force you to think a specific way, whereas books allow us to imagine without boundaries.
Reading the book is more affective in our life; as we are ask to read in everyday life. Practicing reading skills is also good because we are basically practicing another communicating skill. Although we can be lacking in time, so we may watch the movies to get the basic idea, we should always try to read the book. Like mentioned previously, reading can almost recreate a “movie” behind our eyelids, and this specific characteristic, can never be replaceable from some ordinary film. Therefore, if you are in a hurry, watching the film may be better thing to do. But if you got the time, it is highly recommended that you read the book. Both films and books possess their own special characteristics; some may find films interesting, others may find it distorting.